How to Turn a Mystery into a Full-Class Mock Trial

What happens when you combine a murder mystery with a mock trial?

You get one of the most engaging middle school ELA activities students will remember all year.

In this special bonus episode, Caitlin walks you through exactly how to combine two favorite EB Academics resources:

• The “Bountiful Case” murder mystery
• The EB Mock Trial template

The result is a full-class courtroom experience where students analyze evidence, build arguments, write claims, present cases, and debate what really happened to Walter Bountiful.

Even better?

Both resources are completely free inside the downloadable bundle mentioned in this episode.

Whether you need a high-engagement end-of-year activity, a creative argumentative writing project, or a memorable way to teach evidence-based writing, this episode will show you exactly how to make it work in your classroom.

Throughout the episode, Caitlin breaks down:

• How to introduce the mystery
• Ways to build student buy-in
• How to organize the courtroom roles
• What trial day actually looks like
• How this connects directly to evidence-based writing instruction

If you have ever wanted to run a mock trial but felt intimidated by the setup, this episode will help you simplify the process and confidently bring it to life with your students.

HERE ARE THE 3 KEY TAKEAWAYS FROM THIS EPISODE:

1. Mock trials make argumentative writing feel real.
   Students become far more invested when they are writing to persuade a jury instead of simply completing an assignment for a grade.
2. Engagement skyrockets when students take ownership of roles.
   From attorneys to jurors to courtroom journalists, students become deeply invested in the learning experience.
3. You do not need to build a mock trial from scratch.
   The free templates, outlines, rubrics, and courtroom materials make the process simple and manageable for teachers.

RESOURCES MENTIONED IN THIS EPISODE

Free Mystery + Mock Trial Bundle

EB Teachers ELA Portal

MORE FROM EB ACADEMICS

If you want engaging, standards-aligned ELA lessons that students genuinely love, the EB Teachers ELA Portal gives middle school teachers access to complete curriculum, argumentative writing resources, discussion activities, interactive lessons, and classroom engagement strategies designed specifically for grades 5–8.

SUBSCRIBE & REVIEW

If this episode gave you new ideas for argumentative writing and classroom engagement, please subscribe and leave a review on Apple Podcasts. It helps more middle school ELA teachers discover practical teaching strategies that actually work.

Listen to this episode of the Teaching Middle School ELA Podcast

👉 Listen on Apple Podcasts
👉 Listen on Spotify